[JW Lua] Weird accidental behaviour

[Robert Patterson]

Maybe the difference is that I am using F26.3 (Mac) to import the file,
because I am seeing correct behavior from LoadAt. But clearly this is *not*
a F02 file because it has a .musx extension. If you want to send the
original .mus I will be happy to try it.

That said, the thing I would check before anything else is the note detail
flag on that entry. (You can check it with...the enigma text dump plugin!)
Loss of entry bits is common. Finale itself tends to ignore them, but I
notice the PDK Framework does not. (You can download the PDK Framework
source code for yourself at Jari's website. It's a very old version, but
LoadAt is in there.)

So the first thing I would do to repair the file is set the note entry bit
and then see if LoadAt starts behaving properly again.


On Wed, Jul 8, 2020 at 11:51 AM Jan Angermüller <jan at angermueller.com>
wrote:

> It doesn't work with the Finale test file from the first email (I have
> attached it again).
> That one was created with Finale 2002a and probably is not compatible with
> current Finale versions.
> See my two screenshot videos with these weird behaviours in the first
> email.
>
> 1.) This file returns false with LoadAt.
> 2.) But it actually seems to have a hidden value -54 EVPU (which can be
> seen in the Youtube videos)
> 3.) Through manual movement I can reproduce this -54 EVPU value.
> 4.) The anchor point of the accidental suddenly jumps when I click it ->
> see video. It seems that the hidden FCAccidentalMod used in this document
> had a different alignment option which is not available in Finale anymore
> and causes this weird behaviour  (as you said and as I guessed it probably
> has to do with a deprecated Finale option which is not correctly imported
> into Finale 2014)
> 5.) But I cannot get this value automatically: i.e. when I load the
> accidtest.musx document and run the script immediately, it will always
> return 0 EVPU and not -54 EVPU. So the FCAccidentalMod seems to be somehow
> hidden.
> -> That's what my question is about.
>
> As I said my Perfect Layout accidental placement script normally works.
> This is the first document where the automatic FCAccidentalMod reading
> doesn't work. The code snippet that I posted is just for testing purposes.
> The Perfect Layout script is much more complex, but it's not relevant here.
>
> What I want is:
> - Read the current horizontal position of the accidental (usually 0 EVPU
> as there is usually no FCAccidentalMod, if there is an FCAccidentalMod read
> this value). He
> - Change the current position by adding a small value (e.g. 10 EVPU)
> - Accidtest returns the wrong horizontal position by default
>
> If I add a value to this accidtest.musx document, it moves the accidental
> to the wrong position.
> Because 0 EVPU (which usually is the position before the notehead) is in
> this case the wrong reference position.
> When I save an accidental mod with HorizontalPos=1 EVPU to this accidtest,
> it moves the accidental by 55 EVPU and not by 1 EVPU.
>
> Jan
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Am 08.07.2020 um 18:33 schrieb Robert Patterson:
>
> With your script, running on your file, FCAccidentalMod:LoadAt returns
> true if there is an acci mod and false if there isn't one. What's the issue?
>
> If the question is, "where did that -54 come from?", the answer is Finale
> calculated it and put it there. I wouldn't worry about where it came from.
> Instead, I would set the value you want and save it. Don't forget to set
> the note detail flag on FCNoteEntry.
>
> If you are not seeing the results you think you should see after running
> your script, use my plugin to compare the changes made by your script to
> those identical changes done manually. That will show you what your script
> is lacking.
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> JWLua mailing list
> JWLua at jwmusic.nu
> http://jwmusic.nu/mailman/listinfo/jwlua_jwmusic.nu
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://jwmusic.nu/pipermail/jwlua_jwmusic.nu/attachments/20200708/93803567/attachment.htm>